Bumpy return for night trains in Europe

Night trains have made a comeback in Europe thanks to their low carbon footprint – but after years of neglect, the renaissance has had a bumpy ride. Operators admit that the trains are outdated – with passengers facing occasional delays, technical problems or malfunctioning toilets – while companies compete in an overloaded network.

Despite the challenges, nation al rail operators are giving night trains another chance while startups are jumping on the bandwagon as climate concerns are making travellers ditch planes for cleaner modes of transportation.

A revival and growing demand

Sitting at the crossroads between western and eastern Europe, Austria has been at the heart of this revival with the backing of the government even as low-cost airlines threatened to relegate sleeper trains to the history books. Austrian rail operator OeBB, a pioneer in the sector, has Europe’s biggest fleet of night trains, serving 1.5 million passengers in carriages that include bed compartments.

The state-owned company considered abandoning its overnight services at one point, but it went in the opposite direction and invested in them instead. “Our night trains are nearly fully booked,” said OeBB spokesperson Bernhard Rieder as summer travel is in full swing in Europe.

OeBB runs 20 routes connecting Vienna and other cities throughout Europe. “We have a long tradition with night-train service,” said Rieder, pointing out how the Alpine nation’s mountainous topography makes having high-speed connections difficult. Astrid Reiter, a 27-year-old consultant, booked a night train from Vienna to Zurich. “It’s nice because you basically wake up in a different country,” she said. “If everything works out well, it’s a very convenient way to travel.” She added: “I hope that other companies other than the Austrian railway company develop more night trains and make it easier to have faster night trains.”

ALSO READ: Not your standard safari: 10 unexpected experiences in Southern Africa

Challenges and upcoming improvements in night train services

Rieder admitted that the quality of its service “is not always as high these days as what we want to deliver to our customers”. “There was no demand and no request for night trains for over 25 years” causing manufacturing to grind to a halt, he said. In 2018, OeBB ordered 33 new night trains from German conglomerate Siemens to expand its reach and replace part of its ageing fleet.

The first trains – with a modern design, more privacy and more shower facilities – are expected to go into service at the end of this year. Chris Engelsman, co-founder of the Belgian-Dutch startup, European Sleeper, also complained about a shortage of “proper night-train coaches”. Established in 2021, his company inaugurated a Berlin-Brussels link in May. “The train is not always up to modern standards, but despite that many people would like to travel by night train and the enthusiasm is quite big,” he said.

Competition, investment, and infrastructure overload

“There are breakdowns sometimes or the toilets are not working or electricity is not working properly, things like that,” he added, blaming the “lack of investment for decades”. Competition from low-cost flights and a lack of coordination between different European rail operators and companies are other obstacles.

It’s difficult to compete with some flights’ “unreasonably low” prices, according to a recent report by NGO Greenpeace, with the aviation sector benefitting from subsidies and tax exemptions. On the other hand, rail transport is “subject to various taxes and fees,” in particular for using the infrastructure, said Philipp Kosok, an analyst at the German think-tank, Agora. “Operating night trains is very difficult, complex and expensive,” he said. He added that the infrastructure was “overloaded” even at night when freight trains ply the rails.

Startups aim to revamp night trains and create a competitive alternative to aviation

There is also no centralised site to consult timetables and compare prices, with some in the industry complaining of a lack of political will. “There’s not really a European approach to train travel at the moment,” Engelsman said. French startup Midnight Trains co-founder Adrien Aumont said his company’s aim was to “reinvent” the night train “to make it a truly competitive means of transport against aviation”.

Aumont had the idea to create the company when his partner “decided never to get on a plane again”. His startup is partnering with a night-train maker to relaunch the once popular Paris-Milan Venice line in 2025.

“I realised that it was almost impossible to travel in Europe (without flying). “People were asked to get off the planes, but without necessarily offering them solutions,” he said. He slammed a service that “has deteriorated” over time, which is far from the legendary and luxurious Orient Express.

NOW READ: Western Cape’s Sweet and succulent Calitzdorp