Avatar photo

By Heinz Schenk

Journalist


Springbok player ratings: Mediocrity all round

There were exceptions - albeit just a few - but the Test in Washington wasn't a great day to showcase the depth of Bok rugby.


Here’s how the Springboks fared on their first ever trip to Washington.

15 – CURWIN BOSCH (3/10)

Hardly made any claim for a long-term stay in the fullback position. Seemed to follow the kick-based tactics to the letter … and to his detriment.

14 – TRAVIS ISMAIEL (5/10)

Given the overall context of the Boks’ performance, this wasn’t a bad debut for the Bulls winger. Poached his try well but should’ve tried to dot down a second time when he was bundled into touch.

13 – JESSE KRIEL (5/10)

Did brilliantly with his quick hands to make Mapimpi’s try a certainty. His off-loading game is become a strength.

12 – ANDRE ESTERHUIZEN (7/10)

How this man has improved within a year. Showed vision and finesse with a superb break and kick forward early in the first half. A storming dart set up the Boks’ second try. Solid on defence too. He’s staked a claim to become a first-choice player for Rassie Erasmus.

11 – MAKAZOLE MAPIMPI (6/10)

Who said this man is a one-trick pony? Showed his try-scoring ability by dotting down on debut but his real triumph was his work rate without the ball. Chased high balls all day and completed 8 tackles. Really promising.

10 – ELTON JANTJIES (5/10)

This was a typical Jantjies performance of 2018. Solid in the goal-kicking department, inconsistent everywhere else.

9 – IVAN VAN ZYL (5/10)

No fireworks but as John Mitchell will tell you, that’s not this Bulls scrumhalf’s game. Calm in sticky situations and his distribution reliable.

8 – DAN DU PREEZ (3/10)

Disappointing day at the office for the towering No 8. His handling was really poor and conceded two turnovers.

7 – OUPA MOHOJE (6/10)

Deserves credit for gradually imposing himself during the game. Looked very rusty initially – he hasn’t played for a few weeks since the Cheetahs’ Pro14 run finished – before carrying well, tackling hard and being an extra lineout option.

6 – KWAGGA SMITH (5/10)

His hands were disappointingly poor for a sevens star but he delivered a mountain of work on defence – an immense 12 tackles.

5 – PIETER-STEPH DU TOIT (6/10)

As always led by example with a solid all-round performance though his captaincy debut was less glittering.

4 – JASON JENKINS (6/10)

There was a Bakkies Botha vibe to his performance. Certainly potential for a so-called enforcer role in future.

3 – WILCO LOUW (4/10)

Did his part on defence but conceded a scrum penalty and didn’t carry much.

2 – CHILIBOY RALEPELLE (6/10)

Showed his experience in delivering a solid performance. Robust defence and one very good turnover.

1 – OX NCHE (3/10)

Difficult debut for the young Cheetahs prop. Shot out of the line too early in the build-up to one of Wales’ tries and had to be lectured by the referee about his struggles in the scrum.

16 – AKKER VAN DER MERWE (5/10)

Bustling as ever. Certainly injected energy and made his tackles as the game became a bit looser.

17 – STEVEN KITSHOFF (4/10)

Stabilised the scrum but conceded a penalty and a turnover. Didn’t deliver the usual magic.

18 – THOMAS DU TOIT (5/10)

Did nothing prominent but also didn’t do anything wrong.

19 – MARVIN ORIE (7/10)

Brilliant cameo from the Lions man. Carried well, made two tackles and stole two lineouts within a 17 minute stint.

20 – SIKHUMBUZO NOTSHE (6/10)

Worthy replacement for the out-of-sorts Dan du Preez. Deserves more opportunity.

21 – EMBROSE PAPIER (NOT ENOUGH TIME TO BE RATED)

One lovely break in the dying seconds.

22 – ROBERT DU PREEZ (3/10)

At least nailed his first penalty goal for the Boks but had two kicks charged down within two minutes. One of them led to Wales’ winning try.

23 – WARRICK GELANT (6/10)

Provided far more than Bosch.

For more news your way

Download our app and read this and other great stories on the move. Available for Android and iOS.

For more news your way

Download our app and read this and other great stories on the move. Available for Android and iOS.