Outrage over Motsepe saying only SA’s educated can ‘look at the facts’

Patrice Motsepe has caused outrage on Twitter for comments which some have slammed as being insulting towards the poor.

The billionaire businessman was responding to reports that he would benefit from the unbundling of Eskom recently announced by President Cyril Ramaphosa, who also happens to be his brother-in-law.

Motsepe was recounting words which late former president Nelson Mandela said to him.

“It’s appropriate to start with what Nelson Mandela said at [a] meeting,” he said, which according to Motsepe was: “You see, Patrice, whether you like it and accept it, you and others have become protectors of the system.”

READ MORE: Motsepe denies accusations that he will benefit from Eskom unbundling

“What he meant is that we have at all times to behave in a manner that is not just compliant with the law but also… which is ethical,” the businessman said. “But what is critically important [is also to] deal with perceptions.

“That’s why over the last twenty years it’s been important what we do as a family, it’s not just what the facts are, it’s not so much our compliance with the law. It’s how are you perceived – you know, this wealthy family, this wealthy person, when you mention our names in the minds of ordinary South Africans.”

It was then that Motsepe let slip with the comment that has drawn outrage: “… and be careful, we are not talking about your educated South Africans and even not so much your middle class because they can look at the facts and form an opinion …

“We are living in a time when it’s elections and lots of issues are going to be said but we are a democracy and even if I didn’t have these relatives in government I have a fundamental duty and an obligation not just to be transparent, but also to be ethical and accountable.”

Motsepe

Mandela said, you've become protectors of the system

When you mention our names in the minds of ordinary SAns. We're not talking about educated or middle class as they can look at facts & form opinions

Even if I didn't have these relatives in govt, I have to be ethical pic.twitter.com/7A0yvNLKtO

— Izwe Lethu (@LandNoli) February 18, 2019

Motsepe’s apparent view that “middle class” South Africans are better able to “look at the facts and form an opinion” than their poorer counterparts was not well received.

The backlash he received on Twitter included users who said what Motsepe said was insulting, that he was “trying to disrespect” the poor and that he was being “classist”.

One user said that if you’re poor you are “assumed stupid and gullible” as well as “constantly infantilised”.

Mxm 😒😒Motsepe watelela. He thinks just because the system didn’t allow ALL educated majority to be a part of this silly class system he can just insult us like that. Masepa gae le post yagoba gatekeepeer. Mxm https://t.co/3emoV0z32F

— upsetblakgal (@upsetblakgal) February 18, 2019

But it's the educated and middle class that formed these rumours mos. is Motsepe trying to disrespect the Poor or ini? https://t.co/VbHfk9gW43

— Sedii (@mabontleSasa) February 18, 2019

Motsepe says they're not worried about the perceptions of "Educated, or middle class, who are able to listen to facts and form an opinion"… lol if you're poor, or without formal education, you're assumed stupid and gullible, constantly infantilised.

— Nhlamulo Mabasa (@E_xcelsior) February 18, 2019

I think the educated ones call this: a Freudian slip. Because it hints at a worldview that resonates with such statements. But this being SA let's wait for Motsepe to clarify what he was saying.

— Melo Magolego (@melomagolego) February 18, 2019

Ashidiwe! Patrice Motsepe on some classist talk. Basically he is saying that people who are either not educated or not middle class, may not look at facts and thus may not form informed opinions.

South Africa, e reng poverty and inequality? https://t.co/seFSRlyJyQ

— Melo Magolego (@melomagolego) February 18, 2019

That presser didn’t sound like a smart educated Motsepe . Sounded more like a Thuma Mina denial social. This elite have convinced us they are smart but when you give them an ear there’s Dololo.

— African Legend (@AfricanLegendZA) February 18, 2019

Motsepe’s comments were made at a briefing to dispel allegations of nepotism after President Cyril Ramaphosa announced during his state of the nation address that Eskom would be unbundled into three entities.

The businessman denied claims that the unbundling of Eskom would benefit his firm African Rainbow Energy and Power.

(Additional reporting by Gopolang Chawane)

For more news your way, download The Citizen’s app for iOS and Android.