carine hartman 2021

By Carine Hartman

Chief sub-editor


Not me, your honour

It’s like our muti killings in the name of culture: I don’t understand.


He was 15 and in love. So he penned his feelings to the 14-yearold object of his adoration – but the villagers descended on his house, dragging him by his hair down the road.

His screaming mother followed, pleading for his life. But they threw him in front of a moving train. His sin? He was of a lower caste than the girl.

I read the three paragraphs hidden on page two of a national Sunday paper more than a decade ago and decided this boy couldn’t die in vain.

He needed a book blowing Death by Dishonour wide open. I gave up. Not that the caste system is too complicated. It’s just taboo.

My Hindi friend explaining the system shook his head many a time. I heard “it’s complicated”; “religion”; “you won’t understand”; “culture”.

So I forgot about it until, during my Corona binge-watching, I stumbled upon The Stoning of Sorayah M.

Apparently based on truth, the story is simple: hubby wants to take a child bride and frames his wife, telling the Pakistani small-towners she is having an affair with a widower.

And so his honour is revenged. If only life imitated movies. I find honour killings in India, Palestine, Asia – but especially Pakistan.

The latest, in May, when two women were murdered after a “disgusting” video of a man kissing them on the mouth leaked.

A father and a brother were arrested, but, despite a new law fixing a loophole for killers to escape prosecution, old-school “I forgive you” by the victim’s family still rules supreme.

The law came three months after Qandeel Baloch, a social media star and feminist, was killed by her brother for dishonouring the family – one of about 1,000 honour killings a year in Pakistan,

Human Rights Watch tells me. Iran is worse: also in May, Reza Ashrafi beheads his 14-year-old daughter, Romina, for running away with a 29-year-old man.

Ashrafi will get away with it because religious leaders oppose change to Iran’s antiquated laws. I despair at humanity.

Like barbarians, we kill children, marry them off, trade them in sex rings, beat up women, murder them – and we hide behind culture, heritage, religion, manhood, honour…

So yes, my Hindi friend, you’re right. It’s like our muti killings in the name of culture: I don’t understand. And not in my name.

For more news your way, download The Citizen’s app for iOS and Android.

For more news your way

Download our app and read this and other great stories on the move. Available for Android and iOS.