carine hartman 2021

By Carine Hartman

Chief sub-editor


Giving pinkies the finger

Pink liberals always make the right noises, but their racism is thinly veiled as elitism. But I dare to dream.


Sometimes I think I’m no more than that species I despise so: the slightly pink liberal standing on the street corner doing the un-Zulu finger-pointing of “Zuma must go, Zuma must go” – thanks for the vision, Trevor Noah.

But I have a Martin Luther King dream.

Admittedly a pink dream because it’s not mine. It’s a condescending dream for a lady who is ever so slightly illiterate (read: no ways will she finish a bewildering course on finance and housing) and all she’s ever wanted was a house. Her house. I’ve seen it over the six years since Diketso came into my life: my age; still scrubbing floors; still
dreaming about Her Place that she hopes to leave to her daughter’s Aids baby, now going into matric.

Yes, she gets the promising phone calls at election time; she applied for an RDP house just after ’94 – and last year, she got it.

“But it’s outside Vereeniging, not where I work. Far…” She was right to turn it down. But, like me, time is running out
for Diketso – so I started dreaming. We have a “bad” building (read: a policeman who died alone and
the city took over his house) on the main road hardly a block from where Diketso lives in squalor.

The pink community, ever vigilant and ever unforgiving, earmarked it a risky property with “drug dealings; criminals hiding”.

But I dreamt: I asked council if they will give Diketso a lease on the property they pay R2 000 a month for just for security (to keep the pinkies happy), although it is stripped bare. They listened. A form landed in my inbox asking me to present “a plan”.

And a plan I have: prime property on a main road with public transport opposite a park – a dream for city’s vision of densification around green areas and blending low-cost housing into the “more affluent suburbs”.

I’m costing, planning, promising myself the container city on that property won’t be more than three storeys because of the neighbours. I know they will complain, the pinkies who “really care for the underprivileged – but my view is gone, you know”.

And that’s the problem: pink liberals always make the right noises, but their racism is thinly veiled as elitism. But I dare to dream.

Read more on these topics

Columns racism

For more news your way

Download our app and read this and other great stories on the move. Available for Android and iOS.