Jacob Rees-Mogg, a British Conservative politician and a hardline supporter of Brexit, has caused controversy by making comments that were seen by many as justification for the use of concentration camps by British colonialists during the Anglo-Boer War.
Rees-Mogg appeared on BBC One’s Question Time talk show, where he defended Winston Churchill’s legacy, saying he should not be vilified like Adolf Hitler.
He then said that the death toll suffered in concentration camps used by the British was the same as the death toll in Glasgow at the same time.
“South African concentration camps had exactly the same mortality rate as existed in Glasgow did at the time. They’re not a good thing but where else were people going to live?” he said.
He was then taken to task for justifying an atrocity by another guest on the show, researcher Grace Blakley.
He denied this, saying people were only put in these camps “for their protection”.
“I’m afraid you are confusing concentration camps with Hitler’s extermination camps,” he continued.
“I’m not saying they are the same thing. I’m saying any concentration is de facto an awful, awful thing,” was Blakley’s response, after which Rees-Mogg tried to explain himself.
“These people were interned for their safety. Now that is not a good thing. The death rate was exactly the same as Glasgow. Death rates 100 years ago were considerably higher than they are now for all sorts of reasons,” he said.
“It was not systematic murder. That is simply wrong. I’m not advocating people being taken off their farms and put into camps but there was a war going on and people were being taken there to be fed because the farmers were away fighting the Boer War.
“This is one of the things where you’ve got to understand the history of what was going on, not just look at it from the comfort of 2019 and say that this is the same as what was going on with Hitler. It is completely and utterly different.”
Watch the clip below:
Rees-Mogg was slammed on social media by both South Africans and Brits for insensitivity, Indy100 reports, by people including veteran South African journalist Max du Preez.
The concentration camps used in the Second South African War are considered to be one of the greatest atrocities committed by the British.
Over 27,000 of the 107,000 people interned in the camps died. This amount was a sixth of the Boer population at the time. Most of those interned were women and children, and they largely fell victim to starvation and disease due to the appalling conditions that were allowed to persist.
A report after the Boer war concluded that 27,927 Boers (of whom 24,074 were children under 16) had died of starvation, disease and exposure in the #concentrationcamps #JacobReesMogg @Jacob_Rees_Mogg #BBCQuestionTime #bbcqt @graceblakeley #Glasgow pic.twitter.com/0naY32BU5n
— Make Piers Disappear (@PiersDisappears) February 14, 2019
This is outrageous and disgusting revisionism >> BBC News – Jacob Rees-Mogg comments on concentration camps https://t.co/mxNHm9wHm7
— Max du Preez (@MaxduPreez) February 15, 2019
Jacob Rees Mogg just defended the use of concentration camps by the British Government by saying the life expectancy in a South African concentration camp was the same as that in Glasgow under the British state. #BBCQT
— ????????????????????????????CHRISTOPHER McEleny???????????????????????????? (@SNPChris) February 14, 2019
Jacob Rees-Mogg explaining that Boer women and children were put in concentration camps for their protection. And to be fed. And then saying “you have to understand the history” or something to that effect. ???? https://t.co/BozjflkcbZ
— Ryan Coetzee (@RyanCoetzee) February 15, 2019
OMG is @Jacob_Rees_Mogg for real? Boer war concentration camps were the same as life in Glasgow. Women and children were starved to death! The fact that women and children were starving in Glasgow at the same time (for different reasons) is just #FuckTheTories every time #bbcqt
— Linda Scott (@sindalott) February 14, 2019
Utter nonsense by @Jacob_Rees_Mogg The Boer women & children were taken to #ConcentrationCamps, not for their safety or to feed them, but to stop them providing the #boer soldiers, engaged in gorilla tactics, with food and supplies. More #fakenews https://t.co/4JubZRN7Pk
— James Endersby (@JamesEnders) February 15, 2019