Soup kitchens can no longer be policed or controlled, court says

Food parcels that are to be handed out to community members at the Denver Mens Hostel arrive. Picture: Tracy Lee Stark (Note, this picture is for illustrative purposes only.)

The government can no longer prevent the distribution of food during the Covid-19 national lockdown after a non-governmental organisation (NGO) – 1 000 Women Trust – approached the courts and won the right to freely assist the hungry.

In a statement released on Sunday, 1 000 Women Trust said the Department of Social Development “proposed to control, manage and determine who can run a soup kitchen”.

“It wants to centralise donations. The 1 000 Women Trust says no. Keep your hands off the soup kitchens. The communities and non-profit organisations (NPOs) will decide how and when to provide food,” the statement said.

A founding member of 1 000 Women Trust, Tina Thiart, said they were happy to work with the government, but they would not be dictated to.

“We are working with the [Department of Social Development] in our province, and, where possible, we want NPOs to collaborate with the government, but we will not be told what to do. We know the communities we operate in,” she said.

Thiart asked the general public to keep on supporting NPOs and soup kitchens.

“Give your time, money and goods in kind. All people have the right to food and the right to share their resources,” she said.

The 1 000 Women Trust, a well-known South African NGO, approached the Cape Town High Court in its case against Social Development Minister Lindiwe Zulu and Police Minister Bheki Cele.

The case appeared before Judge Robert Henney on Friday.

The NGO approached the high court after Zulu’s department announced a proposed ban on soup kitchens and circulated draft directives that prevented the distribution of food by NGOs.

Thiart said the draft directives were issued two weeks ago and “have been applied, even though they have not been legally processed”.

“A large number of food relief organisations were told by the police or by officials of the [department] to stop distributing food.”

She said Judge Henney’s order now effectively “halted the process by which the Department of Social Development can prevent the distribution of food by NGOs”.

Thiart said the court instructed the social development minister to bring the order of the high court to the attention of all officials in her department as well as the MECs responsible for social development in every province.

“The matter has been postponed for a further hearing in the Cape Town High Court on 19 June, 2020.”

We will never stop anyone, but our people must have dignity

Speaking to News24 on Sunday evening, the minister said the social development department had repeatedly said it never wanted to stop organisations from helping South Africans.

“I want to make it clear that there is no way in hell that I can be standing in front of people who want to distribute food. We are understanding the plight of people at this point in time – the last thing one can do is stop people from distributing food to the hungry,” said Zulu.

She said there were, however, protocols that had to be followed.

“There is social distancing and wearing of masks. There is a virus that is transmitted from one person to the next. All we are asking for from people is to please adhere to those protocols – please make sure you don’t get a lot of people coming out and standing in long queues without proper monitoring and people assisting them, so they don’t infect each other.”

She also called for dignity for South Africans.

“If we are doing these things, we ought to do it with dignity. Let me tell you, as a person who struggled to get SA to where it is today, nothing pains me more than seeing people pushing and jostling for food. It is a very painful picture to see.”

She added: “We are just having conversations about how we can best protect our people.”

For more news your way, download The Citizen’s app for iOS and Android.



today in print