Airbnb vs hotel: Which to choose when travelling to the US

Depending on your travel destination, you might be better off booking a hotel over an Airbnb.


Airbnb has long been used as the default lodging for travellers looking for affordable accommodations. But new findings show that depending on your travel destination, you may be better off booking a traditional hotel.

If you’re headed to New York, for example, digital business publication Fit Small Business recommends booking a hotel room over Airbnb to get more bang for your buck.

Because while Airbnb listings are about 7% cheaper than New York hotel rooms, they’re also likely to be much smaller and cramped compared to a hotel room given the notoriously small size of condos and apartments in the Big Apple, report authors say.

New York City. Picture: iStock

Given the sheer number of hotels — New York has the highest number of hotels in the US — guests have no shortage of choice.

Similarly, the sky-high cost of housing in San Francisco also translates to higher Airbnb rates, making hotel rooms the more favourable choice, points out the report.

On the other hand, in Anaheim, where housing costs are relatively low, guests are better off booking with Airbnb.

For the report, editors looked at hotels versus Airbnb listings in 15 of the most visited cities in the US, and looked at factors like price, amenities, availability, location and regulatory environment.

San Franciso. Picture: iStock

Here’s a look at the best cities for hotels vs Airbnb:

Best for hotels
New York City
Atlanta
Los Angeles
Las Vegas
Seattle
San Diego
San Francisco
Orlando

Picture: iStock

Best for Airbnbs
Anaheim
Chicago
Philadelphia
San Antonio
Austin
St. Louis
Miami Beach
Orlando

For more news your way, download The Citizen’s app for iOS and Android.

Read more on these topics

Airbnb hotel

Access premium news and stories

Access to the top content, vouchers and other member only benefits