Is SA’s great mall building boom over?

Buried on slide 49 of the annual results of one of the country’s largest retail real estate investment trusts¹ are the following four words: “Retail market reaching maturity”. This is one of the first admissions by a major participant in the sector that the market is increasingly saturated and South Africa simply doesn’t need much more retail space.

We have the sixth highest number of shopping centres in the world, according to 2015 research by the South African Chamber of Shopping Centres. At that point, there was under 2 000 of them covering over 23 million square metres.

Admittedly, Vukile Property Fund (the Reit reference above) tends to be active in the small regional (25 000m²-50 000m²) and community (12 000m²-25 000m²) shopping centre segments (68% of its portfolio, by market value). This is where much of the growth has been in recent years, with centres being built in townships and smaller towns in every corner of the country (as well as in whatever gaps there were as major metros continued to sprawl).

At the mega end of the market, commentators have been quite clear that Mall of Africa is likely the last super regional (>100 000 m²) shopping centre to be built in this country for a while. There’s simply no obvious need for yet another giant mall.

Trading densities (sales growth per square metre of space) are under pressure, with “regional, small regional and super regional segments… now some way off their three- and five-year average year-on-year growth rates” according to the South African Property Owners’ Association Retail trends report for the year to end 2016. The super regional segment actually showed a decline in trading densities of 1.2% year-on-year.

Source: MSCI Real Estate (SAPOA Retail trends, March 2017)

The (effective) failure of Stuttafords will affect vacancies across the sector, as well as likely knock earnings of those funds affected (as landlords). Hyprop CEO Pieter Prinsloo told the Financial Mail last week that “it is likely to take six months to negotiate lease agreements with new tenants and fit out new stores”. Hyprop-owned Canal Walk, Rosebank Mall, and Clearwater Mall are affected. And while there is demand from international retailers (like H&M, Zara and Cotton On) for space, this has moderated.

But retail is about more than just shopping centres. An analysis by Moneyweb of building statistics collected by StatsSA since 2000 reveals a clear trend.

Source: Stats SA preliminary annual figures, collation by author

When looking at both building plans passed by municipalities across the country for ‘shopping’ and the amount of space actually reported as completed, it’s apparent that a peak has been reached.

There is obviously a lag between the approval of building plans and their completion. Additionally, there is no direct correlation between a plan being passed and it being completed (some planned developments simply do not happen and some are not reported as complete).

In 2016, preliminary data shows a decline of a full 200 000m² of space planned – or 20% – when comparing it to the year prior. That’s almost two Mall of Africas! The data is lumpy (a huge project like that would’ve affected the national numbers in the year plans were passed), but one can clearly see the recession and its after-effects in 2010, 2011 and 2012. Based on space, plans approved in those years more than halved from the peaks in two of the five years prior. In that boom from 2005, over 1 million square metres of shopping space was approved per year.

On a ‘reported as completed’ basis, the long run average since 2000 has been 528 000m², while over the past decade, that has shot up to 583 000m² . The last five years, however, have all been below the decade average.

JJL’s Q1 South Africa Retail Market Report lists just three developments in its pipeline which are over 50 000m² : the 85 000m² Cornubia Shopping Mall (opposite Mount Edgecombe in Durban), Sky Mall near OR Tambo International in Johannesburg (85 000m²) and Table Bay Mall (60 000m²) at Blue Bay in Cape Town. The remaining dozen are far more modest….

Brought to you by Moneyweb