Steenhuisen says Dlamini-Zuma should be sacked for ‘lying’ about tobacco ban submissions

Presidential hopeful Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma sits before the first plenary at the ANC National Elective Conference at Nasrec, Johannesburg on 16 December 2017. Dlamini-Zuma is seen as one of the leading candidates alongside current Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa. Picture: Yeshiel Panchia

The DA leader claims the minister is ‘clearly’ lying to South Africans in order to further her own pre-determined agenda.

The Democratic Alliance (DA) leader John Steenhuisen has called for President Cyril Ramaphosa to sack Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta), Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma for lying about her reason behind the continued ban on the sale of tobacco.

“It appears that Minister Dlamini-Zuma lied to South Africans in her justification for the continued ban on the sale of cigarettes and other tobacco products. If this is indeed the case, then President Ramaphosa surely has no choice but to fire her from his cabinet,” he said in a statement on Friday.

Steenhuisen said that last month Minister Dlamini-Zuma claimed that government’s decision to prohibit the sale of tobacco products was partly based on “more than 2,000” public submissions supporting such a ban during in a media briefing of the regulations for lockdown Level 4.

ALSO READ: British American Tobacco to take legal action over cigarette ban

“These alleged submissions formed part of 70,000 public submissions made to government at the time. In this briefing, the minister said: ‘Even in the public comments, there was quite a lot of opposition. More than 2,000 people opposed it.’

“She went on to say that government took that into consideration, debated the matter, looked at it, and decided that we must continue as we are when it comes to cigarettes, tobacco and related products, and that we should not open up the sale of these products.

“But her responding papers to a court challenge by the Fair-Trade Independent Tobacco Association (Fita) paints an entirely different picture,” he said.

The DA leader said the 4,000-page response included all the public submissions she could find to support her actions.

“Plus, it seems, many that had nothing to do with cigarettes or tobacco at all. And the actual opposition to cigarette sales turns out to be a mere fraction of what she had claimed.

“According to Fita, the applicants in the case, there weren’t more than 2,000 submissions attached as evidence. Instead, there were only 1,535 submissions and of these, 47.2% had nothing to do with cigarettes or smoking, 23.3% were in favour of smoking and only 29.6% supported the ban, which amounts to just 454 submissions,” he added.

Steenhuisen went on to claim that the minister was “clearly” lying to South Africans in order to further her own pre-determined agenda.

“The question is when the minister said on live television that government took that into consideration, debated the matter, looked at it,” was she implicating the rest of the National Command Council (NCC) in this lie, or did she herself deceive her cabinet colleagues?

READ MORE: Malema slams tobacco ban as ‘abuse of power’ while Ramaphosa has effectively ‘quit’ as No 1

“Either way, this conduct renders her wholly unfit to occupy the position of a cabinet minister, and particularly one with such sweeping powers under the Disaster Management Act. Of course, it should be immaterial whether 2,000 or 454 people wrote in to support the ban.

“This has never been the basis for the formulation of any other lockdown regulations. And, had the president himself not assured South Africans mere days earlier that cigarettes would go back on sale under Level 4, the submissions opposing the ban would most likely have dwarfed any support,” he continued.

He further said the fact that the minister took the decision to make up “a number of alleged supporting submissions and then lie to the public should be grounds for immediate suspension from her position”.

“If the president wants to salvage some credibility for government’s response to this crisis, he cannot allow her to evade accountability on this,” he concluded.

(Compiled by Molefe Seeletsa)

For more news your way, download The Citizen’s app for iOS and Android.



today in print