Jacques Pauw slammed for ‘pathetic’ focus on ‘dope-smoking Rastafarian’

Investigative journalist Jacques Pauw has released an article calling into question Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane’s recently released report finding that Minister of Public Enterprises Pravin Gordhan had violated the constitution through his involvement in the so-called “rogue unit” at Sars.

Pauw reports that one of Mkhwebane’s main sources was a former Sars employee who Mkhwebane presented as a “specialist agent” at Sars but who told Pauw he knew nothing about the “rogue unit”.

READ MORE: Mkhwebane’s chief ‘rogue unit’ source says he knows nothing about it – report

The source, named as Keletso Bizoski “JahRa” Manyike, is described as an “unemployed, dope-smoking Rastafarian”.

The reaction to the story on social media has seen some questioning whether this portrayal of Manyike is relevant or fair.

Acclaimed author Zakes Mda expressed this view: “I’m just wondering how his religion and the fact that he enjoys weed comes into play in the whole story. If he was Catholic and enjoyed ice cream would the story have unfolded differently? This is a genuine question because I don’t know the story yet,” he tweeted.

Others have had a stronger reaction. One user described the Sunday Times as a “downgrade” for suggesting that a “‘pot-smoking Rastafarian’ cannot be a credible witness”, while another described the focus on Manyike’s religion as an “unnecessary, bigoted” “ad hominem attack” and a “degenerate affront to the constitution”.

“It’s pathetic how low they’ve stooped,” said another user.

“The story still had weight without the attack on his person,” said yet another.

Pauw did not respond to questions sent by The Citizen. However, he told Eusebius McKaiser on 702 that he “should have told the Sunday Times to cut” the angle of Manyike being an “unemployed, dope-smoking Rastafarian”.

“I apologise if I caused any hurt or discomfort,” he added.

Why is it relevant that the guy smoked marijuana and is a member of the Rastafari community and unemployed? "I apologise" says @Jaqqs and continues "I should have told the @SundayTimesZA to cut that out (the framing)". @Radio702

— Eusebius McKaiser (@Eusebius) July 15, 2019

.@Jaqqs "I apologise if I caused any hurt or comfort" says Jacques when I suggest the framing is sensationalism and tabloidisation." @Radio702

— Eusebius McKaiser (@Eusebius) July 15, 2019

Meet the unemployed Rastafarian who #Mkhwebane says was a major source for her 'explosive' report on Gordhan and Sars 'rogue' unit. https://t.co/MkUFJ90k3o

— Sunday Times (@SundayTimesZA) July 14, 2019

I’m just wondering how his religion and the fact that he enjoys weed comes into play in the whole story. If he was Catholic and enjoyed ice cream would the story have unfolded differently? This is a genuine question because I don’t know the story yet https://t.co/O13X11FKaR

— Zakes Mda (@ZakesMda) July 13, 2019

https://twitter.com/36litcandles/status/1150306364889194496

That "pot-smoking rastafarian that knows nothing" shot was unnecessary, bigoted & just the kind of ad hominen attack one attempts when flailing.

It is a degenerate affront to the constitution.
🙂

— Ottilia Anna MaSibanda (@MaS1banda) July 14, 2019

Sad that @SundayTimesZA had to use his religion and lifestyle to discredit him. Being Rastafarian and smoking pot aren’t negative traits.

The story still had weight without the attack on his person.

— O (@kgadi_ZA) July 14, 2019

I the article they actually call him an unemployed, dope smoking Rastafarian. Its pathetic how low they've stooped

— Tessa Dooms (@Tessa_Dooms) July 14, 2019

https://twitter.com/Mr_Stoloro/status/1150271759725289472

Mkhwebane recently released a report resulting from an investigation into Gordhan, which the public protector said was conducted “under extremely difficult conditions”, and contained the bombshell that the so-called “rogue unit” was real.

Mkhwebane also found that Gordhan lied to both parliament and the Zondo commission of inquiry into state capture when he said he couldn’t recall meeting members of the controversial Gupta family.

Mkhwebane said the allegation of the establishment of a Sars intelligence unit – often called the rogue unit – is substantiated, and that Gordhan should have been aware of the unit while operating as Sars commissioner. She added that he believes that he “was aware”.

Mkhwebane said Gordhan’s conduct relating to the intelligence unit violated the constitution.

READ MORE: The knives are out between Mkhwebane and Gordhan

Gordhan, according to Mkhwebane, played a role in recruiting Johan Van Loggerenberg to the unit.

Mkhwebane also said she possessed evidence that would prove that intelligence equipment was procured for use by the unit, and that this equipment was procured improperly. She says Sars has not provided her with the information she requested on this equipment.

According to the public protector, former Sars head Oupa Magashula lied under oath about the existence of the unit.

The public protector also found that former Sars deputy commissioner Ivan Pillay’s appointment was irregular. A previous report found the same regarding the approval of Pillay’s early retirement by Gordhan.

UPDATE: Jacques Pauw’s comments on 702 apologising for his description of the source as an “unemployed, dope-smoking Rastafarian” and saying it should have been removed from his Sunday Times report were added. 12:43, July 15. 

For more news your way, download The Citizen’s app for iOS and Android.